The Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism (CBAM) and its possible impact on UK companies

The Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism (CBAM) is a crucial policy tool developed by the European Union (EU) to tackle carbon leakage and drive global climate action. Carbon leakage occurs when companies move their production to countries with less strict emission regulations, undermining local and global climate efforts to cut emissions.

Here's a comprehensive overview of how CBAM functions and its key components:

Objectives:

Levelling the Playing Field: By imposing a carbon price on imports of certain goods from outside the EU, CBAM ensures that EU products are not disadvantaged compared to imports from countries with less stringent carbon regulations.

Incentivizing Global Emission Reductions: Encouraging other countries to adopt more rigorous climate policies by making the carbon cost of their exports to the EU transparent.

Mechanism:

Scope: Initially targeting sectors at high risk of carbon leakage such as cement, iron and steel, aluminium, fertilizers, and electricity.

Calculation: The carbon content of imported goods is calculated based on their production emissions. Importers are required to report the carbon emissions embedded in their products.

Certificates: Importers must purchase CBAM certificates equivalent to the emissions embedded in their imported goods. The price of these certificates is linked to the price of carbon under the EU Emissions Trading System (ETS).

Exemptions and Adjustments: Countries with carbon pricing mechanisms equivalent to the EU ETS might receive exemptions or adjustments to avoid double charging for carbon and to recognize efforts made by other countries to curb emissions.

Implementation:

Transition Phase: Starting with a reporting phase where importers need to monitor and report emissions without paying for certificates, providing time for adjustment.

Full Implementation: Gradual introduction of the payment obligation based on reported emissions, ensuring a smooth transition for businesses.

Challenges and Criticisms:

Complexity: Accurately calculating the carbon content of imports can be technically challenging and administratively burdensome.

Trade Relations: Potential for trade disputes as non-EU countries may view CBAM as a protectionist measure.

Compliance and Enforcement: Ensuring compliance across numerous importers and products can be difficult.

Benefits:

Environmental Integrity: Helps maintain the effectiveness of the EU’s climate policies by reducing carbon leakage.

Economic Fairness: Ensures that EU businesses are not unfairly disadvantaged by stricter domestic climate regulations.

Global Impact: Encourages global efforts toward reducing greenhouse gas emissions, fostering international cooperation in climate policy.

In summary, the CBAM is an innovative approach to mitigate carbon leakage, promote fair competition, and drive global climate action by ensuring that the carbon cost of goods is considered regardless of their production location.

UK Status under CBAM:

The United Kingdom (UK), after Brexit, is not a part of the European Union (EU) and hence not directly covered by the EU's policies, including the Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism (CBAM). However, the UK's trade relations with the EU mean that UK exporters must comply with CBAM regulations when exporting covered goods to the EU.

Potential Implications for the UK:

Compliance Costs: UK exporters in sectors like cement, iron and steel, aluminium, fertilizers, and electricity will need to monitor and report carbon emissions, and potentially purchase CBAM certificates.

Alignment with UK Policies: If the UK implements its carbon pricing mechanisms effectively, it might mitigate some compliance costs under CBAM. Harmonization with EU standards could simplify processes for UK businesses.

Trade and Negotiations: The UK might seek negotiations with the EU to ensure favourable terms, potentially arguing for recognition of its domestic carbon pricing mechanisms to reduce double charging risks.

Major Countries Facing Challenges with CBAM:

CBAM is likely to pose significant challenges for countries with less stringent carbon emission regulations compared to the EU. Here are some major countries that could face difficulties:

China:

High Emissions: China is a major producer of steel, aluminum, and cement, all high-emission sectors.

Economic Impact: Compliance with CBAM could increase costs for Chinese exporters, potentially impacting trade volumes with the EU.

Regulatory Alignment: China would need to strengthen its carbon pricing and regulatory frameworks to align with EU standards, which may be challenging given its current industrial policies.

India:

Industrial Output: India is a significant producer of steel and aluminium, with relatively high carbon emissions in these sectors.

Economic Growth: Balancing economic growth with stringent emission regulations can be difficult, and CBAM compliance might increase production costs.

Policy Adjustments: India may need to implement or enhance carbon pricing mechanisms to mitigate CBAM impacts, which could face domestic political and economic resistance.

Russia:

Energy Exports: Russia's economy is heavily reliant on fossil fuel exports, and the energy sector is a major carbon emitter.

Export Costs: CBAM could significantly raise the costs for Russian exports to the EU, particularly in energy-intensive sectors.

Regulatory Changes: Russia would need substantial policy shifts towards carbon regulation and pricing, which might be challenging given its current economic and political landscape.

Turkey:

Proximity and Trade: As a close trading partner to the EU, Turkey's industrial sectors like cement and steel will be directly impacted by CBAM.

Economic Adjustments: Compliance costs could affect Turkey's competitiveness in the EU market.

Policy Harmonization: Turkey would need to align its carbon policies with EU standards, which might require significant regulatory changes.

Mitigation Strategies for Affected Countries:

Adopting Carbon Pricing: Implementing domestic carbon pricing mechanisms to align with EU standards.

Improving Emissions Monitoring: Establishing robust systems for monitoring and reporting emissions accurately.

Investing in Green Technologies: Encouraging the adoption of low-carbon technologies in industrial sectors.

Negotiating Trade Terms: Engaging in diplomatic negotiations with the EU to seek exemptions or favourable terms under CBAM.

In summary, while the UK needs to adapt to CBAM requirements for its exports to the EU, major challenges will be faced by countries with high emissions and less stringent carbon regulations, such as China, India, Russia, and Turkey. These countries will need to undertake significant policy and regulatory adjustments to mitigate the impact of CBAM on their exports to the EU.

Contact JWS Consultants for further information and support